Who really wins in the Spelling Bee?

Another year, another desi kid wins the Scripps National Spelling Bee, a few reports appear in the newspapers, and otherwise the event is mostly forgotten.  There are the usual gaggle of desi participants – a third of the semi-finalists had desi origins, and for the fourth year in a row, the winner was an Indian-American – Sukanya Roy.

I watched the questions get tougher and tougher through the final rounds, and soon you had reached a stage where knowing the rules of etymology no longer had any benefit.  There were words from Turkish, Arabic and Tagalog, and every world language you could think of.  You could not guess the spelling from a Greek or Latin root, you had to Know the word.  You could see the clear difference in the quality of participants between the preliminary rounds and the finalists.  The finalists were so good that the organizers had to throw tougher and tougher words at them in a desperate attempt to get them to stumble and have the field reduced to one or two.

Sukanya Roy wins the 2011 Scripps National Spelling Bee (Pic: Washington Post)

Sukanya Roy wins the 2011 Scripps National Spelling Bee (Pic: Washington Post)

You wonder how many hours these finalists would have devoted to learning spellings, as compared to the hours those other kids who had aced their Districts and failed in the preliminary rounds.  You wonder what the kids get out of all the stupendous hard work they have put in.

Sure, they learn discipline and hard work, perseverance, etymology, an amazing vocabulary, a very good command of English, and the ability to perform under pressure.  But all this is common to anyone who gets even to the preliminary rounds.  What rewards do those extra-ordinary semi-finalists and finalists get?  After all, while the winner gets around $37,500 in cash and bonds, and $2,600 worth of books, and some of the other finalists get attractive prizes, all that most of the participants (including semi-finalists) would get is a small gift card and a chance to visit Washington D.C.  The gift card would not even compensate them for their expenses in staying in D.C. for the competition, so it would be meaningless.

The organizers, on the other hand, are probably raking in the profits.  Starting from tickets to the event (at $40 per head for 2000 people) to sale of Spelling Bee memorabilia, to the TV rights, not just in the US but elsewhere too.  I’m sure the Spelling Bee is telecast in Canada (we did have a Canadian runner up and other Canadian participants) and possibly in the Caribbean.  This year, I noticed that ESPN telecast the Spelling Bee semifinals and finals  live in India, and I wonder where else they did so – Pakistan? Sri Lanka?   Does Sky telecast it in the UK?

You can certainly make a case for increasing the prize money for all participants, given how fast this competition is growing and the profits this show must surely be making.

But what I worry more is not that the participants are not benefiting monetarily, my worry is that the emphasis on the TV ratings may potentially change the nature of the competition.  As it is, many of these desi winners are not good at providing soundbytes  that the organizers would like.  You can see the disappointment in the face of the organizers who try to coax out a few words from the stunned, suddenly shy child.  Do the kids jump up in joy,  pump their fists, kneel on the stage and kiss the ground, or cry or show any emotion at all?  Not really, they just suddenly become speechless, and even look a little stupid.  It is bad enough to have robotic answers during the competition, but to continue to remain robotic after winning does not make for good TV.

There are the occasional crowd favorites, like Surjo Bandyopadhyay this year and Samir Patel in previous years, who are showmen, making for great TV. But most of the other kids just stick to an almost robotic manner of  behavior – asking the same predictable questions, answering unemotionally.  It’s not just the desi kids who do this, but with so many desi kids in the competition, one cannot help but wonder if this is a common attribute among all the desi kids.

I wonder whether, as the competition grows (which would be presumably more internationally as  more world TV audiences are drawn in), whether the organizers would not feel more pressure to make the competition more TV friendly.  I’m not sure what form this would take, and whether it would somehow confer any subtle advantage on the showman-style kids.  But on the whole, I don’t see it as a very good development for the participating kids.

To sum up, I don’t believe the kids are reaping the benefits of the show’s increase in popularity as much as the organizers are.  What’s worse is whether they are likely to get adversely affected by its continuing increase in popularity.

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Who really wins in the Spelling Bee?

  1. Much as I love the English language and am a stickler for correct spelling and all that, I really dunno if I would watch a Spelling Bee on TV 🙂 Might it not be seen as personal geekiness taken to the absolute nadir?

    Even if they increased the prizes and made it more lucrative for the participants, I doubt the programme would become another X Factor or somesuch.

    • I think people watch it more for the kids (I know I do). Agree with you that it’s definitely going to be a niche show at the best of times, and should do better in geekier households 🙂 I certainly can’t see the reality-TV watching crowd watching the Bee.

  2. Winning a Spelling Bee always comes down to who
    “knew” or memorized the most words apart from knowing the patterns,etymology etc. The Bees have therefore become very predictable because Desi kids who are coached by their parents excel at employing rote learning techniques which is basically pattern recognition and pattern matching.What would make the show little less predictable and more fun is – if they would ask the contenstant to use the word in a sentence and then score that for correct usage, creativity, humor etc.

  3. I do not understand the productivity of this entire paraphernalia. There are better, healthier and funner 🙂 ways to learn discipline, perseverance and hard work. Apart from the prize money and a line in SOP to increase your chances to get in Ivy league how is it helping kids to become better person. How often these kids are going to use these unheard antiquated words, and even if they try to use one, imagine they being avoided by less worders :). Even if they aspire to be writers, journalists or spokespersons how the breadth of knowledge of words going to help them dwell deeper in their ideas? Seriously when is the crusade of middle class parenting going to end?

  4. What is the big deal with spelling bees? Or for that matter, quiz shows? Memorizing trivia and regurgitating it in front of an audience is hardly a feat that deserves applause. In fact, now that I think about it, spelling bees are probably a step higher, requiring the contestants to at least go about figuring their answers by deducing the words’ etymology, etc.

    I actually started reading the post thinking I’d finally figure out why so many Asians win these contests with such regularity. Still puzzled.

    I really like your blog, BTW. The above was me just thinking aloud.

  5. The bees have a cult following among many Indian Americans. They even have THEIR OWN (of their own, for their own,by their own) organizations promoting the bee culture where everyone breathes and speaks the language of the bees and they breed more and more bees of the same kind there. As with all cults their aim is to promote their own bee culture and philosophy. So you see this phenomenon where year after year the same type of kid from the same cult win a bee and speak the same scripted lines on TV after winning “We are competing against a dictionary to win, not against a person”. “We are infact a community which is why we are so successful” – How profound!!!!

    For most, the real world is full of people of all kinds not dictionaries or computers. Guess for some the real world is not real – the world of dictionaries or computers is………..

  6. There are more desi on spelling bee as they have no life wasting time on books when they should be thinking about better things to do

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s